After the success of 1985’s Re-Animator, director Stuart Gordon and writer Dennis Paoli wanted to adapt another Lovecraft story. They wanted to film Lovecraft’s 1923 short story The Lurking Fear, but Empire Pictures’ collapse canceled the project. Years later, C. Courtney Joyner, who previously wrote Prison for Empire Pictures, directed Trancers III: Deth Lives for Full Moon. Studio head Charles Band was pleased with the sequel, so he offered Joyner the chance to resurrect the Lovecraft adaptation. At the time, Band found success shooting in Romania after filming the Subspecies franchise, so they filmed at Buftea Studios. They brought on Empire/Full Moon veteran Jeffrey Combs, alongside Ashley Laurence, Vincent Schiavelli, and Jon Finch. Unfortunately, Joyner and Finch did not see eye-to-eye, as Finch disagreed with Joyner’s direction and made the experience rough. Despite these setbacks, Lurking Fear finally hit video store shelves in July 1994.
%
Rating
Synopsis
After being released from prison, John Martense (Blake Adams) goes to his childhood town of Lefferts Corner. He meets up with family friend Knaggs (Vincent Schiavelli), a local mortician who’s been holding onto part of a map. The map shows the location of a hidden stash of money left by Martense’s father after his last heist. He follows the map to an abandoned church, where he meets Cathryn (Ashley Laurence) and Dr. Haggis (Jeffrey Combs). It turns out that underground monsters have repeatedly attacked the town, and Cathryn lost her sister to the creatures. Soon enough, master thief Bennett (Jon Finch) and his accomplice Ms. Marlowe (Allison Mackie), arrive looking for the stash. Soon enough, the underground dwellers make their way into the church, and the group has to make a stand. Who will survive the onslaught, and who will be the next victim of the lurking fear?
Review
Compared to other Lovecraft adaptations from Charles Band, Lurking Fear isn’t as good as Re-Animator or From Beyond. That said, this film has plenty going for it, from the moody atmosphere and the solid cast. Blake Bailey, who later starred in Head of the Family, gives a good performance as a rugged ex-con. Ashley Laurence stands out as the formidable female lead who’s willing to show some vulnerability without seeming weak. On top of looking good with a beard, Jeffrey Combs is fun as the snarky and pessimistic chain-smoking doctor. Vincent Schiavelli has some good moments with Blake Bailey, but his role is more like an extended cameo. Even if he was awful to work with, Jon Finch still makes for a great and imposing villain. Allison Mackie, who was also Joyner’s cousin, has a great femme fatale look and works well along with Finch.
The movie has a similar “mobsters vs. monsters” vibe as 1985’s Transmutations, but Joyner does a much better job. While that film ruined its approach to combining horror with film noir, this one manages to balance the tone out. Even before the monsters show up, Joyner manages to create a foreboding mood that’s reminiscent of old gothic horror films. Once the monsters show up, it becomes a gruesome onslaught similar to the climax in From Dusk Till Dawn. If there are any problems with the film, I’d say that we don’t get to know our main characters much. We’re given just a basic setup for them before they’re thrown into an explosive climax with copious amounts of gore. While this doesn’t have the lasting power of Stuart Gordon’s adaptations, this one will provide enough entertainment for 75 minutes. Overall, Lurking Fear is an underrated gem that’s worth uncovering.
Buy Lurking Fear on Amazon: https://amzn.to/3BBkztZ.
Disclosure: The above link is an affiliate link, which means that, at zero cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through the link and finalize a purchase.
